Gehman Accounting vs Smoker & Company LLC: Lancaster Area, PA Bookkeepers Compared (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Gehman Accounting: Evidence Score 53 at 78% coverage. Smoker & Company LLC: 47 at 75% coverage.
- Neither says anything about pricing on its site.
- By their own account, Gehman Accounting serves construction, retail and transportation businesses, while Smoker & Company LLC names retail, manufacturing and agriculture.
Sources cited in this article: Firm's own website, State business registry, and our published methodology.
How this list is built: Methodology · Disclosures · About · Report a correction
At a glance
| Gehman Accounting | Smoker & Company LLC | |
|---|---|---|
| Rank on the Lancaster area list | 1 of 7 | 2 of 7 |
| Evidence Score | 53/100 at 78% coverage | 47/100 at 75% coverage |
| Documented services + buyer fit | 35 of 40 pts | 27 of 40 pts |
| Independently verifiable qualifications | 0 of 20 pts | 0 of 20 pts |
| Operational + pricing transparency | 7 of 25 pts | 9 of 25 pts |
| Verified identity + continuity | 11 of 15 pts | 11 of 15 pts |
| Office locality | New Holland, PA Self-reported | Leola, PA Self-reported |
| Software supported | Dext, QuickBooks Online (5 pts) Self-reported | QuickBooks Online, QuickBooks Desktop (5 pts) Self-reported |
| Pricing approach published | Not documented | Not documented |
| Active CPA firm or individual license (state board) | Not verified | Not verified |
| Current QuickBooks ProAdvisor or Xero advisor listing | Not verified | Not verified |
| Entity found in the state business registry | Business registration found: Gehman Accounting, Inc. · PA filing no. 0003832639 · Pennsylvania Department of State · Active (6 pts) Third-party | Business registration found: Smoker & Company Llc · PA filing no. 0004081484 · Pennsylvania Department of State · Active (6 pts) Third-party |
| Years operating (registry formation date) | Formed 2008-09-02 (creation date of a Pennsylvania-formed entity) (5 pts) Third-party | Formed 2011-12-30 (creation date of a Pennsylvania-formed entity) (5 pts) Third-party |
A search that found nothing reads "Not verified": it is not a mark against a firm (how we search).
Full evidence profile: Gehman Accounting · Full evidence profile: Smoker & Company LLC
Where they differ
| Scored item | Gehman Accounting | Smoker & Company LLC |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly bookkeeping (8 pts) | Documented (8 pts) | Not documented |
| What is included / excluded (5 pts) | Not documented | Documented (5 pts) |
| Onboarding described (4 pts) | Not documented | Documented (4 pts) |
| Reporting cadence stated (4 pts) | Documented (4 pts) | Not documented |
| Named contact / team (3 pts) | Agents BigCommerce, Partner (3 pts) | Not verified |
What both document
AP / AR; Payroll coordination; Month-end close + reporting; Industries served (documented); Local / remote model stated
Our read
On the Lancaster list, Gehman Accounting leads Smoker & Company LLC by 6 points, 53 to 47. Most of the difference sits in documented services, where Gehman Accounting has 35 of 40 points to 27.
Gehman Accounting works from New Holland, names construction, retail and transportation among the industries it serves, works in Dext and QuickBooks Online and has a state registration dated 2008.
Smoker & Company LLC works from Leola, names retail, manufacturing and agriculture among the industries it serves, works in QuickBooks Online and QuickBooks Desktop and has a state registration dated 2011.
What neither documents: catch-up work, pricing and how they keep in touch. Ask each firm directly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for catch-up work, Gehman Accounting or Smoker & Company LLC?
Neither site mentions catch-up or cleanup work, so ask both before you commit if you're behind.
Do Gehman Accounting or Smoker & Company LLC publish prices?
Neither says anything about pricing on its site. Each profile quotes the page the wording came from.
Where are Gehman Accounting and Smoker & Company LLC based?
Both appear on the Lancaster list: Gehman Accounting lists an office in New Holland, and Smoker & Company LLC lists one in Leola.
Sources and further reading
Dates are when we checked. Report an error.
- Firm's own websiteChecked Sep 26, 2026
- State business registryChecked Sep 26, 2026
- How the Evidence Score worksBookkeeping Index methodology
- Commercial disclosuresBookkeeping Index